When it comes to premium beard care, two names dominate the conversation — Beardbrand and Honest Amish. Both are well-respected brands with loyal followings, but they offer very different approaches to grooming. Whether you’re a minimalist or a traditionalist, understanding the differences can help you choose the right products for your beard and lifestyle.
Brand Overview
Beardbrand
Founded in 2012, Beardbrand focuses on modern grooming and self-expression. Their products are designed for the beardsman who wants sophistication, style, and subtle fragrance.
Philosophy: “Keep on growing” — Beardbrand emphasizes individuality and confidence through personal care.
Popular Products:
- Beardbrand Utility Balm
- Beardbrand Beard Oil (Tree Ranger, Old Money, and Tea Tree scents)
- Beard Wash and Softener
Signature Traits:
- Lightweight, non-greasy formulas
- Clean, masculine scents
- Sleek modern packaging
Honest Amish
Honest Amish is all about traditional craftsmanship and organic simplicity. Their products are handmade in small batches using all-natural ingredients, reflecting a back-to-basics approach to beard care.
Philosophy: Authenticity and purity — rooted in old-world recipes and natural oils.
Popular Products:
- Honest Amish Beard Balm
- Classic Beard Oil
- Beard Wax and Beard Soap
Signature Traits:
- 100% natural and organic
- Earthy, subtle scents
- Rich, conditioning formulas
Beard Oil Comparison
Beardbrand Oil is lighter and absorbs quickly, making it ideal for daily use or shorter beards. The scent profiles are refined and modern — perfect for someone who prefers a “clean cologne” vibe.
Honest Amish Oil is thicker and richer, better suited for dry climates or longer beards. Its natural aroma is subtle but earthy, appealing to those who value organic simplicity.
Verdict:
- Beardbrand for light, everyday use and stylish fragrance.
- Honest Amish for deep conditioning and natural nourishment.
Beard Balm Comparison
Beardbrand Utility Balm offers medium hold with a smooth finish, perfect for taming flyaways without stiffness.
Honest Amish Beard Balm has a heavier, waxier consistency that deeply conditions and provides stronger hold.
Verdict:
- Beardbrand for styling flexibility.
- Honest Amish for hydration and control.
Scent and Feel
Beardbrand leans toward modern, scent-driven profiles — clean, professional, and refined.
Honest Amish focuses on natural, earthy tones — herbal, warm, and subtle.
Verdict:
Choose Beardbrand if you like fresh, cologne-inspired fragrances.
Choose Honest Amish if you prefer a raw, all-natural scent experience.
Price and Value
- Beardbrand: Premium price tag with sleek branding and lifestyle appeal.
- Honest Amish: More affordable, especially for all-natural ingredients.
Verdict:
Beardbrand feels luxurious, while Honest Amish delivers exceptional value for money.
Overall Winner
Both brands excel, but for different reasons:
- Beardbrand is best for men who value grooming as part of their personal style.
- Honest Amish is ideal for those who prioritize natural, no-frills care.
Final Take: You can’t go wrong with either — it comes down to personality. Want refined and modern? Go Beardbrand. Want classic and earthy? Go Honest Amish.
Key Takeaways
- Beardbrand: sleek, light, and modern.
- Honest Amish: natural, rich, and traditional.
- Both offer high-quality products tailored to different lifestyles.